Search


CNG Bidding Platform

Information

Products and Services



Research Coins: Electronic Auction

 
320, Lot: 675. Estimate $100.
Sold for $120. This amount does not include the buyer’s fee.

FRANCE, Provincial. Normandie. Circa 1075-1130. AR Denier (18mm, 0.99 g, 11h). + NORMANNIΛ, patriarchal cross; pellets flanking base / Church pediment, containing pellet, surmounted by cross; on each side, letters P A X within semicircles. Dumas, Group C, pl. XX, 23; Le Gros 335; Poey d'Avant –; Duplessy, Féodales –; Roberts –. Near VF, traces of hard green on obverse.


Le Gros connects this issue to William's PAXS type in England, circa 1083-1087, and the form of the legend, with the letters PAX within nearly circular lobes clearly has an affinity for the reverse style of William's issue. However, in addition to this PAXS type, there were three other PAX issues that were struck in relative proximity to it: Edward the Confessor struck his PACX type in 1042-1044, Harold II struck his PAX issue in 1066, and Henry I struck a PAX type in 1103. Of course, neither Edward or Harold could possibly have struck a Norman issue during their reign, but perhaps the Norman coinage was influenced by the English types? This issue is somewhat simplified by J.C. Moesgaard's analysis of the Norman coinage in light of numerous hoards (“Monnaies normandes dans les régions baltiques à l’époque Viking,” RN 161 [2005]). He was able to place the various nameless Norman coinage into general date ranges. He dates Dumas Group C, to which this PAX issue belongs, to c. 1075-1130. This dating excludes the possibility of a connection to the Anglo-Saxon issues of Edward and Harold. At the same time, Moesgaard's dating does not exclude an Norman issue analogous to the English issue of Henry I. While the type here is stylistically more similar to William's type (as noted above), his issue used the legend PAXS, not PAX, which is more similar to the issue of Henry. Nevertheless, the interpretation of the various PAX type by S. Keynes (“An interpretation of the Pacx, Pax and Paxs pennies,” Anglo-Saxon England 7 [1978]), as an invocation of Christ, shows that the addition of the C (in Edward's Pacx) and S (in William's PAXS), were done for the purpose of symmetry in a four-part reverse formed by a long cross, which was not necessary on the three-letter PAX issues of Harold and Henry. Thus, the use of the three letter form on the Norman issue is predicated on the three-sided pediment around which they appear, and therefore is not necessarily reflective of the exact issue it may be associated with in the English coinage.